Rating Voivodinian municipalities based on the efficiency of their SMEs in agribusiness
Rangiranje opština Vojvodine na osnovu efikasnosti poslovanja MSP u agrobiznisu
Abstract
The paper represents continued research by the group of authors (Maletić et al., 2011, 2012) conducted on the same data with the objective to apply new statistical methodologies to measuring entities' business efficiency and their ranking. For these purposes the distance based analysis (DBA method) was applied in order to estimate the agribusiness efficiency of SMEs in Vojvodina. Ranking of municipalities was first conducted based on Ivanovic distance, separately for input and output indicators, which were then normalized by L metrics. The final estimation of SMEs' business efficiency and the ranking of municipalities were determined by dividing the obtained normalized values. A comparative analysis of the results of the two applied methodologies (Ivanovic distance and DBA) showed significant discrepancies, i.e. that they produce inconsistent results. Although statistical indicators indicated relatively close relationship between the resulting ranks, further research showed that the de...viations are significant. Therefore, it was concluded that the choice between the two methods depends only on the decision-makers and the research objectives.
Rad predstavlja nastavak istraživanja grupe autora (Maletić i dr., 2011, 2012) na istoj bazi podataka u cilju primene novije statističke metodologije za merenje efikasnosti poslovanja entiteta, kao i za njihovo rangiranje. U tu svrhu je primenjena analiza zasnovana na odstojanju (DBA metoda) kojom je ocenjena efikasnost poslovanja agrarnih, malih i srednjih preduzeća u opštinama Vojvodine. Rangiranje opština je najpre izvršeno Ivanovićevim odstojanjem posebno za ulazne i izlazne indikatore, koji su potom normalizovani L metrikom. Krajnja ocena efikasnosti poslovanja MSP, kao i konačan rang opština je definisan deljenjem dobijenih normalizovanih vrednosti. Uporedna analiza rezultata primenjene dve metododologije (Ivanovićevo odstojanje i DBA metoda) je pokazala da postoje značajna odstupanja i da se rezultati jedne metode ne mogu poistovetiti sa rezultatima druge. Iako statistički pokazatelji ukazuju na relativnu blisku vezu dobijenih rangova, dalja izvodjena su ukazala da su odstupanja... značajna. Iz tog razloga, primena neke od ovih metoda zavisi isključivo od donosioca odluke i cilja istraživanja.
Keywords:
Statistical estimation of efficiency / I-distance / distance based analysis - DBA / small and medium enterprises - SMEs / Statističko ocenjivanje efikasnosti / I-distanca / analiza zasnovana na odstojanju-DBA / mala i srednja preduzećaSource:
Agroekonomika, 2014, 43, 63-64, 39-49Publisher:
- Univerzitet u Novom Sadu - Poljoprivredni fakultet - Departman za ekonomiku poljoprivrede i sociologiju sela, Novi Sad
Funding / projects:
- Rural Labour Market and Rural Economy of Serbia - Income Diversification as a Tool to Overcome Rural Poverty (RS-179028)
- Develooment and utilization of novel and traditional technologies in production of competitive food products with added valued for national and global market - CREATING WEALTH FROM THE WEALTH OF SERBIA (RS-46001)
Collections
Institution/Community
Poljoprivredni fakultetTY - JOUR AU - Maletić, Radojka AU - Popović, Blaženka PY - 2014 UR - http://aspace.agrif.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/3650 AB - The paper represents continued research by the group of authors (Maletić et al., 2011, 2012) conducted on the same data with the objective to apply new statistical methodologies to measuring entities' business efficiency and their ranking. For these purposes the distance based analysis (DBA method) was applied in order to estimate the agribusiness efficiency of SMEs in Vojvodina. Ranking of municipalities was first conducted based on Ivanovic distance, separately for input and output indicators, which were then normalized by L metrics. The final estimation of SMEs' business efficiency and the ranking of municipalities were determined by dividing the obtained normalized values. A comparative analysis of the results of the two applied methodologies (Ivanovic distance and DBA) showed significant discrepancies, i.e. that they produce inconsistent results. Although statistical indicators indicated relatively close relationship between the resulting ranks, further research showed that the deviations are significant. Therefore, it was concluded that the choice between the two methods depends only on the decision-makers and the research objectives. AB - Rad predstavlja nastavak istraživanja grupe autora (Maletić i dr., 2011, 2012) na istoj bazi podataka u cilju primene novije statističke metodologije za merenje efikasnosti poslovanja entiteta, kao i za njihovo rangiranje. U tu svrhu je primenjena analiza zasnovana na odstojanju (DBA metoda) kojom je ocenjena efikasnost poslovanja agrarnih, malih i srednjih preduzeća u opštinama Vojvodine. Rangiranje opština je najpre izvršeno Ivanovićevim odstojanjem posebno za ulazne i izlazne indikatore, koji su potom normalizovani L metrikom. Krajnja ocena efikasnosti poslovanja MSP, kao i konačan rang opština je definisan deljenjem dobijenih normalizovanih vrednosti. Uporedna analiza rezultata primenjene dve metododologije (Ivanovićevo odstojanje i DBA metoda) je pokazala da postoje značajna odstupanja i da se rezultati jedne metode ne mogu poistovetiti sa rezultatima druge. Iako statistički pokazatelji ukazuju na relativnu blisku vezu dobijenih rangova, dalja izvodjena su ukazala da su odstupanja značajna. Iz tog razloga, primena neke od ovih metoda zavisi isključivo od donosioca odluke i cilja istraživanja. PB - Univerzitet u Novom Sadu - Poljoprivredni fakultet - Departman za ekonomiku poljoprivrede i sociologiju sela, Novi Sad T2 - Agroekonomika T1 - Rating Voivodinian municipalities based on the efficiency of their SMEs in agribusiness T1 - Rangiranje opština Vojvodine na osnovu efikasnosti poslovanja MSP u agrobiznisu EP - 49 IS - 63-64 SP - 39 VL - 43 UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_agrospace_3650 ER -
@article{ author = "Maletić, Radojka and Popović, Blaženka", year = "2014", abstract = "The paper represents continued research by the group of authors (Maletić et al., 2011, 2012) conducted on the same data with the objective to apply new statistical methodologies to measuring entities' business efficiency and their ranking. For these purposes the distance based analysis (DBA method) was applied in order to estimate the agribusiness efficiency of SMEs in Vojvodina. Ranking of municipalities was first conducted based on Ivanovic distance, separately for input and output indicators, which were then normalized by L metrics. The final estimation of SMEs' business efficiency and the ranking of municipalities were determined by dividing the obtained normalized values. A comparative analysis of the results of the two applied methodologies (Ivanovic distance and DBA) showed significant discrepancies, i.e. that they produce inconsistent results. Although statistical indicators indicated relatively close relationship between the resulting ranks, further research showed that the deviations are significant. Therefore, it was concluded that the choice between the two methods depends only on the decision-makers and the research objectives., Rad predstavlja nastavak istraživanja grupe autora (Maletić i dr., 2011, 2012) na istoj bazi podataka u cilju primene novije statističke metodologije za merenje efikasnosti poslovanja entiteta, kao i za njihovo rangiranje. U tu svrhu je primenjena analiza zasnovana na odstojanju (DBA metoda) kojom je ocenjena efikasnost poslovanja agrarnih, malih i srednjih preduzeća u opštinama Vojvodine. Rangiranje opština je najpre izvršeno Ivanovićevim odstojanjem posebno za ulazne i izlazne indikatore, koji su potom normalizovani L metrikom. Krajnja ocena efikasnosti poslovanja MSP, kao i konačan rang opština je definisan deljenjem dobijenih normalizovanih vrednosti. Uporedna analiza rezultata primenjene dve metododologije (Ivanovićevo odstojanje i DBA metoda) je pokazala da postoje značajna odstupanja i da se rezultati jedne metode ne mogu poistovetiti sa rezultatima druge. Iako statistički pokazatelji ukazuju na relativnu blisku vezu dobijenih rangova, dalja izvodjena su ukazala da su odstupanja značajna. Iz tog razloga, primena neke od ovih metoda zavisi isključivo od donosioca odluke i cilja istraživanja.", publisher = "Univerzitet u Novom Sadu - Poljoprivredni fakultet - Departman za ekonomiku poljoprivrede i sociologiju sela, Novi Sad", journal = "Agroekonomika", title = "Rating Voivodinian municipalities based on the efficiency of their SMEs in agribusiness, Rangiranje opština Vojvodine na osnovu efikasnosti poslovanja MSP u agrobiznisu", pages = "49-39", number = "63-64", volume = "43", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_agrospace_3650" }
Maletić, R.,& Popović, B.. (2014). Rating Voivodinian municipalities based on the efficiency of their SMEs in agribusiness. in Agroekonomika Univerzitet u Novom Sadu - Poljoprivredni fakultet - Departman za ekonomiku poljoprivrede i sociologiju sela, Novi Sad., 43(63-64), 39-49. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_agrospace_3650
Maletić R, Popović B. Rating Voivodinian municipalities based on the efficiency of their SMEs in agribusiness. in Agroekonomika. 2014;43(63-64):39-49. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_agrospace_3650 .
Maletić, Radojka, Popović, Blaženka, "Rating Voivodinian municipalities based on the efficiency of their SMEs in agribusiness" in Agroekonomika, 43, no. 63-64 (2014):39-49, https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_agrospace_3650 .